2003 - Amanda McKenzie - Volleyball

2004 - Meghan Magee - Basketball

2005 - Felisa Brown - Basketball

2006 - Melissa Walsh - Field Hockey

2007 - Christy Finke - XC/T&F

2008 - Kristen Greiner - Tennis

2009 - Larkin Kimmerer - XC/T&F

2010 - Anna Lehet - Tennis

2011 - Khadija Campbell - Basketball

2012 - Bri Dunton - Basketball

2013 - Melissa Graham - Basketball

2014 - Bridget McGovern - Field Hockey/Lacrosse

2015 - Lea Sobieraski - Basketball

2016 - Kylie Ryan - Track & Field

2017 - Liz Doherty - Field Hockey

2018 - Kristen Homeyer - XC/T&F

2019 - Taylor Moore - Softball

2020 - Julia Kim - Field Hockey

2021 - Sakura Hamazaki - Swimming & Diving

2022 - Morgan Michalski - Volleyball

2023 - Emily Haber - Volleyball

2023 - Josephine Lewis - Track & Field

2024 - Julia Wallace - Volleyball