2003 - Scott Cappuzzo - Soccer

2004 - Pat McNelis - Swimming & Diving

2005 - Joe Zera - Basketball

2006 - Matt Kuenzel - T&F

2006 - Jack Ryerson - Lacrosse

2007 - Nick Kelley - Basketball

2008 - Tarik Kitson - Basketball

2009 - Scott Morton - Basketball

2010 - Mike White - Swimming & Diving

2011 - Mike Baker - Basketball

2012 - Abe Miller - Basketball

2013 - Ryan Riefenhauser - Basketball

2014 - Ryan Zaremba - Lacrosse

2015 - Sam Thompson - Lacrosse

2016 - Andy Schunk - Swimming & Diving

2017 - Kevin Schaub - Swimming & Diving

2018 - Amman Weaver - Track & Field

2019 Sean Welch - XC/T&F

2020 - Augie Holekamp - Lacrosse

2021 - Tyler Bushnell - Lacrosse

2022 - Sean Beaver - Soccer

2023 - Owen Frank - Soccer

2024 - Christopher Weber - Swimming & Diving