2011 - Michelle Milkovich - Field Hockey

2012 - Anne Beinetti - Soccer

2013 - Abigail Max - Swimming & Diving

2014 - Abigail Max - Swimming & Diving

2015 - Shannon McGinnis - Basketball

2016 - Alexa Wandy - Soccer/Track & Field

2017 - Marissa Cossaro - XC/T&F

2018 - Audrey Reid - Soccer

2019 - Emily Janiszewski - Soccer

2020 - Genny Corcoran - XC/T&F

2022 - Kathleen McCarey - XC/T&F

2023 - Windsor Ardner - XC/T&F

2024 - Tricia Curran - Soccer/Lacrosse