1960s:

1968 - Richard J. Lawton - Baseball; 1969 - Michael Nelson - Basektball/Baseball

1970s:

1970 - Craig Shaw - Soccer; 1971 - James E. Andrews - Lacrosse; 1972 - Geoff Coufal - Basketball; 1973 - James Vogt - Basketball; 1974 - Mike Johnston - Swimming & Diving; 1975 - Dan Parker - XC/T&F; 1976 - Steve Karnath - Swimming & Diving; 1977 - Brian Wolken - Lacrosse; 1978 - James DeWitt - Swimming & Diving; 1979 - Thomas Rapone - XC/T&F;

1980s:

1980 - Joe Bianco - XC/T&F; 1981 - John O'Brien - Swimming & Diving; 1982 - Dale Teed - XC/T&F; 1983 - Dave Montgomery - Ice Hockey; 1984 - Michael Powers - Soccer; 1985 - Matthew Hand - Lacrosse; 1986 - Thomas Foti - Soccer; 1987 - Peter Magnuson - Lacrosse; 1988 - John Kelsch - Soccer; 1989 - Winton Buddington - T&F

1990s:

1990 - Sean Cascio - Ice Hockey; 1991 - Mark Muller - Basketball; 1992 - Thomas Van De Water - Swimming & Diving; 1993 - Charles Healey - Swimming & Diving; 1994 - Jon Hand - Lacrosse; 1995 - Edward Curry - Soccer; 1996 - Brian Fisher - Swimming & Diving; 1997 - Stephen Bancheri - Ice Hockey; 1998 - Matt VanDerMeid - Swimming & Diving; 1999 - Mark Breeden - Ice Hockey

2000s:

2000 - Mike Pacifico - Swimming & Diving; 2001 - Steve Siebrecht - XC/T&F; 2002 - Mike Fox - Soccer; 2003 - Joe Laakso - Swimming & Diving; 2004 - Paul Weismann - Ice Hockey; 2005 - Brett Walker - Ice Hockey; 2006 - Taylor Smith - Soccer; 2007 - Jim Tillapaugh - XC/T&F; 2008 - Derek Jokic - Ice Hockey; 2009 - Steve DuFlo - Lacrosse

2010s:

2010 - Joe Mort - Soccer; 2011 - Bobby Henchen - XC/T&F; 2012 - Ian Mort - Soccer; 2013 - Corbin Rosmarin - Ice Hockey; 2014 - Connor Fedge - Basketball; 2015 - Jack Caradonna - Ice Hockey; 2016 - Sean Fischer - XC/T&F; 2017 - Brad Campion - Soccer; 2018 - Jeff Doser - Swimming & Diving; 2019 - Clark Davis- Swimming & Diving

2020s:

2020 - Sean McAneny - XC/T&F; 2021 - Aaron Mackay - Ice Hockey; 2022 - Riley Grossman - XC/T&F; 2023 - Nicolas Elia - Ice Hockey; 2024 - Cole Kattan - Basketball