1970s:

1975 - Marjorie Herring - Synchronized Swimming; 1976 - Mary G. White - Volleyball/Basketball; 1977 - Kathleen Dowling - Synchronized Swimming; 1978 - Jeannette Pawlik - Volleyball/Basketball; 1979 - Mary E. White - Volleyball/Basketball/Softball

1980s:

1980 - Susan Sarsfield - Volleyball/Softball; 1981 - Jan Holcomb - Basketball; 1982 - Mary Ridler - Swimming & Diving; 1983 - Sharon Smith - Swimming & Diving; 1984 - Lori A. Connor - Volleyball/Track & Field; 1985 - Kim Sickau - Soccer; 1986 - Diane Williams - Basketball; 1987 - Sue Lind - Basketball; 1988 - Julie Rivers - Soccer; 1989 - Eva Barth - Swimming & Diving

1990s:

1990 - Katie Carter - Swimming & Diving; 1991 - Christine Camera - Soccer; 1992 - Krissy DeRycke - Swimming & Diving; 1993 - Kelly Downhower - Volleyball/Softball; 1994 - Betsy Balling - Soccer; 1995 - Katie Smith - Basketball; 1996 - Christine Sisting - Track & Field; 1997 - Amy Cleary - Swimming & Diving; 1998 - Megan Mackey - Basketball; 1999 - P.J. McTigue - Basketball/Soccer

2000s:

2000 - Kirsten Doehler - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2001 - Danielle Schoen - Swimming & Diving; 2002 - Elizabeth Caroscio - Softball; 2003 - Melissa White - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2004- Logan Hadzicki - Soccer; 2005 - Lauren Chatterton - Lacrosse; 2006 - Marta Scott - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2007 - Emily Petraglia - Soccer; 2008 - Amanda Haney - Basketball/Track & Field; 2008 - Shauna Leonard - Lacrosse; 2009 - Lindsey Dressel - Swimming & Diving

2010s:

2010 - Liz Montgomery - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2011 - Michelle Rodriguez - Swimming & Diving; 2012 - Monica Vieth - Tennis; 2013 - Alyssa Smith - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2014 - Caroline Buonocore - Lacrosse; 2015 - Abigail Max - Swimming & Diving; 2016 - Jacqueline Huben - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2017 - Alexa Wandy - Soccer/Track & Field; 2018 - Leah Greene - Soccer; 2019 - Nancy Nasky - Swimming & Diving

2020s:

2020 - Grace Cergol - Volleyball; 2020 - Samantha Reichman - Swimming & Diving; 2021 - Emily Lavarnway - Track & Field; 2021 - Deidra Osula - Swimming & Diving; 2022 - Madison Mulder - Track & Field; 2023 - Gwen Shepardson - Track & Field; 2024 - Windsor Ardner - Cross Country/Track & Field