1960s:

1960 - Don Checho - Soccer/Basketball/Golf; 1965 - Bill Streit - Swimming & Diving; 1966 - James Stewart - Baseball/Basketball; 1967 - James Stewart - Baseball/Basketball; 1968 - Gary Conboy - Baseball/Basketball; 1969 - Michael Nelson - Baseball/Basketball;

1970s:

1970 - Craig Shaw - Soccer; 1971 - Tom Sisson - Basketball; 1972 - Rich Wheeler - Soccer; 1973 - Ed Usinger - Soccer; 1974 - Al Soloman - Wrestling; 1975 - Ed Robota - Basketball; 1976 - Tim Gilliam - Swimming & Diving; 1977 - Charles Reist - Soccer; 1978 - James DeWitt - Swimming & Diving; 1979 - Thomas Gleason - Lacrosse

1980s:

1980 - Tom Metzger - Ice Hockey; 1981 - Joel Stenzil - Swimming & Diving; 1982 - Richard Butterworth - Soccer; 1983 - Chris Manchester - Lacrosse/Soccer; 1984 - Michael Powers - Soccer; 1985 - Paul Dodd - Cross Country/Track & Field; 1986 - Dan Loughran - Ice Hockey; 1987 - Steve Stellwagon - Cross Country/Track & Field; 1988 - Terry Reilly - Ice Hockey; 1989 - Jim Clar - Soccer/Basketball;

1990s:

1990 - Tim Mason - Soccer; 1991 - Chris Smith - Ice Hockey; 1992 - Bill Mason - Basketball; 1993 - Scott Fitch - Basketball; 1994 - Doug Ryan - Track & Field; 1995 - Mark Monaghan - Swimming & Diving; 1996 - Gary Donahue - Cross Country/Track & Field; 1997 - Matt Annabel - Cross Country/Track & Field; 1998 - Mike Houlihan - Swimming & Diving; 1999 - Josh Muldner - Swimming & Diving

2000s:

2000 - Griffin Coles - Basketball; 2001 - Mike Merrill - Soccer; 2002 - Tony Gallo - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2003 - Tim Lennon - Basketball; 2004 - David Spennacchio - Lacrosse; 2005 - Ted Turner - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2005 - Chris Stock - Soccer/Lacrosse; 2006 - Pat Riehlman - Lacrosse; 2007 - Mike Stephens - Ice Hockey; 2008 - Charlie Hake - Swimming & Diving; 2009 - Scott Morton - Basketball

2010s:

2010 - Dennis Costanza - Lacrosse; 2011 - Wills DeMoulin - Swimming & Diving; 2012 - Lee Berube - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2013 - Frank Schiappa - Swimming & Diving; 2014 - Zachary Vit - Ice Hockey; 2015 - John Nasky - Swimming & Diving; 2016 - Kristian Tialios - Swimming & Diving; 2017 - Stephen Collins - Ice Hockey; 2018 - Isaac Garcia-Cassani - Cross Country/Track & Field; 2018 - Samuel Randall - Swimming & Diving; 2019 - Devin McDonald - Ice Hockey

2020s:

2020 - Conlan Keenan - Ice Hockey; 2021 - Matthew Sayre - Cross Country/T&F; 2022 - Don Bosio - Ice Hockey; 2023 - Kieran Sheridan - T&F; 2024 - Nick Andrews - Cross Country/T&F