Don Culligan coached basketball from 1956 to 1973. The team's record was 226-116. His teams won 5 Section IV titles and 4 STAC championships. Three teams were Section IV runners-up. Don served as athletic director for 9 years, introducing female athletics (swimming). He was co-coach of the year for the Ithaca Journal and was elected president of Section IV in 1973 and to the Section IV Hall of Fame in 1981.